Costly, less accurate elections: we oppose LB457 & LB808

On March 22, 2023, Civic Nebraska submitted written opposition to LB457 and LB808. The bills would impose invasive constant video surveillance of voters and require hand counts of ballots, respectively. Here's our testimony on each of these bad bills.

by

In opposition to LB457

LB457 would require video surveillance of voting and provide anti-tampering and anti-counterfeiting requirements for paper ballots, vote scanning devices, and vote tabulating equipment. Ballots distributed at polling places would be under video surveillance from the time they are handed to the voter until they are submitted in the ballot box. The video must be retained for at least three years.

The bill would also require that watermarks, holographs, taggants, and other anti-counterfeiting techniques be used on ballots. All told, the bill would cost more than $6 million, likely with additional annual costs.

Nebraska has had no cases of election fraud. This bill would require a large expenditure of state funds to prevent something that does not exist. Moreover, it could cause many voters to feel uncomfortable being under surveillance while voting their ballot. The resolution of today’s video cameras could enable viewers to zoom in on ballots, compromising the security of each voter’s secret ballot.

For these reasons, we oppose LB457 and encourage the committee not to advance the bill.

In opposition to LB808

The bill allows for the apparent loser in a general election for a seat in the Legislature to specify in his or her petition for a recount that the recount be done by hand count.

LB808 defines a hand count as “a means to conduct a count or recount of ballots by hand, without the assistance of any electronic device or equipment, including, but not limited to, scanners. … A hand count shall also include providing for the comparison and verification of the signature on the envelope holding a ballot for early voting with the signature on file with the election commissioner or county clerk for the respective voter who requested the ballot for early voting.”

The latter part of this provision is problematic because the verification of these signatures is done by comparing it to previous signatures in a voter’s electronic file. The use of a computer is required for this verification, but the bill would require that the count be done “without the assistance of any electronic device.”

A 2018 study by the MIT Election Data and Science Lab found ballot scanners to be more accurate than hand counts. The study focused on two Wisconsin statewide races with recounts, where some localities count ballots by hand and others count them using machines: “In Wisconsin’s 2011 Supreme Court election recount, the hand-counted paper ballots differed from the recount by 0.28 percent while the difference for scanned paper ballots was 0.15 percent. In its 2016 recount of the presidential election, hand-counted paper ballots were off by 0.18 percent while scanned ballots were off by 0.13 percent.” 

Staffing costs for conducting hand counts are also substantially higher. Why would we pay more for less accuracy in our election results?

Follow all election- and civics-related bills at our Bill Tracker page.

Related Articles

‘Fact from fiction’: Our testimony on LB1371

On Feb. 20, 2024, Civic Nebraska Director of Public Policy Heidi Uhing testified in favor of LB1371, which would create new media literacy requirements for K-12 schools in Nebraska. Here is the text of her testimony as prepared.

Media literacy needed for connection

To give youth their best shot at rising to their potential, we need to teach them how to communicate, providing them with hope and resilience.

‘We must stand firm’: Our testimony on LB1042, LB1211

On Feb. 14, 2024, Civic Nebraska director of public policy Heidi Uhing testified in support of LB1042 (automatic voter registration) and in opposition to LB1211 (shortening Nebraska voters’ early-voting window by nearly 40%). Here is her prepared testimony.

5 1 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Locations

After School Programs

  • Sherman Elementary School

    5618 N 14th Ave.
    Omaha, NE 68110

  • Lewis and Clark Middle School

    6901 Burt St.
    Omaha, NE 68132

  • Lothrop Magnet Elementary

    3300 N. 22nd St.
    Omaha, NE 68110

  • Campbell Elementary School

    2200 Dodge St.
    Lincoln, NE 68521

  • Lincoln High School

    2229 J St.
    Lincoln, NE 68510

  • Lincoln Northeast High School

    2635 N. 63rd St.
    Lincoln, NE 68507